The Science Behind Cold Brew
Much of what's said about Cold Brew is based on personal experience and marketing. In recent years, however, the UC Davis Coffee Center, with support from the Coffee Science Foundation and the Specialty Coffee Association, conducted a series of rigorous studies that, for the first time, systematically investigated what happens when we extract coffee cold. The results confirm some popular beliefs, debunk others, and reveal nuances that rarely appear on packaging.
Acidity and Sensory Profile
The most widespread claim about Cold Brew is that it's "smoother and less acidic." To test this in a controlled way, Dr. Mackenzie Batali and the UC Davis team designed a study with 27 samples, three coffees from distinct origins (El Salvador honey, Ethiopia washed, Sumatra wet-hulled), roasted to three levels (light, medium, dark), and brewed at three temperatures (4°C, 22°C, and 92°C). All samples were brewed to extraction equilibrium and diluted to the same TDS (2%) to ensure a fair comparison 1.
The result: Cold Brew did indeed have a consistently higher pH than hot coffee, meaning it is less acidic. In a sensory panel with 14 trained evaluators (1,134 total evaluations), hot coffee was perceived as more "bitter," "sour," and "rubbery," while Cold Brew was more "floral" 1. Interestingly, panelists detected no sensory differences between Cold Brew made in the fridge (4°C) and at room temperature (22°C), good news for anyone seeking convenience, since room temperature reaches equilibrium in ~12 hours versus ~36 hours in the fridge.
There's an important caveat, though: while the differences by extraction temperature are real and measurable, they were considerably smaller in magnitude than the differences caused by the coffee's origin and roast level. In other words, the quality and choice of coffee matters more than the brewing method itself 1.
Extraction Equilibrium
One of the most relevant findings for home Cold Brew enthusiasts comes from the theoretical model developed by Jiexin Liang and colleagues. In full immersion, coffee extraction reaches an equilibrium, a point where TDS stabilizes and no longer increases, even if the coffee remains in contact with water. At equilibrium, the extraction yield (E) hovers around 21%, regardless of the coffee-to-water ratio 2.
What changes with the brew ratio is the final TDS: more water results in lower TDS, and vice versa. But the extraction yield stays constant. This means that, in practice, the main way to control your Cold Brew's intensity is to adjust the ratio, not the time or grind size 2.
Another surprising finding: hot water (92°C) reached equilibrium in ~1 hour, with TDS of 4.27% and EY of 22.28%. Room temperature (22°C) needed ~12 hours (TDS 3.98%, EY 20.74%), and refrigerated water (4°C) needed ~36 hours (TDS 3.76%, EY 19.55%). The difference in EY between cold and hot suggests that certain molecular compounds in coffee simply don't dissolve at low temperatures, even given unlimited time, which partially explains Cold Brew's smoother, less bitter profile 2.
Color in the Cup
During their Cold Brew experiments, researcher Sara Yeager noticed something unexpected: samples brewed cold and hot, even when diluted to the same TDS, had visibly different colors. This led to an investigation that produced 243 unique brews and revealed a consistent pattern: Cold Brews are more reddish, while hot coffees tend toward the classic dark brown-black 3.
In light roasts, the effect is most pronounced, a light roast Cold Brew can appear almost orange. The most likely explanation involves melanoidins, brown compounds formed during roasting via the Maillard reaction, which vary in size and have different solubilities depending on the extraction temperature. The color of the ground coffee, incidentally, does not directly predict the final beverage color 3.
This color difference isn't merely cosmetic. Prior research has shown that more reddish beverages may be perceived as sweeter and less bitter, a phenomenon scientists call the "crossmodal effect," where visual stimuli influence taste perception 3.
Each Coffee Responds Differently
Perhaps the most practical insight from all this research: different coffees respond differently to extraction temperature. Light roast coffees showed no additional sensory differences between Cold Brew and hot coffee beyond those already mentioned (more floral, less bitter). But at medium roast, hot coffee developed "burnt" and "whiskey" notes that didn't appear in Cold Brew. At dark roast, Cold Brew showed more "woody" notes 1.
By origin, the pattern also varies: Ethiopian coffee brewed hot had more perception of "burnt," while cold-brewed it was more "fruity." El Salvador cold-brewed showed more "woody" notes. Sumatra hot-brewed, more "smoky" 1. The practical takeaway is that it's worth experimenting with different origins and roasts specifically for Cold Brew, the profile that works for espresso or hot filter isn't necessarily ideal for cold extraction.
As Vagner Benezath, of Trentino Cafés Especiais, put it: "The quality of ingredients is absolutely essential, since this extraction method brings out sweetness and acidity very evidently. Without quality coffee and water, along with the right technique, you can't have a tasty beverage" 4.





