Defects and Grading
How green coffee is assessed: physical defects, cup defects and the systems used in Brazil and by the SCA.
Quality Starts With the Green Bean
Before roasting, every coffee lot goes through physical grading (how many defective beans are in a sample) and cupping (how it behaves in the cup). Together, these assessments set the price and destination of the coffee.
A single black or sour bean can ruin a whole cup. That is why defect sorting, done with screens, density tables, optical sorters and hand picking, is one of the most important steps in the chain.
To be considered specialty by the SCA, a coffee must pass both tests: very few physical defects and at least 80 points on the cupping table.
Brazilian Official Classification (COB) by Type
Defects are counted in a 300g sample, using the black bean as the reference.
| Type | Defects in sample |
|---|---|
| Type 2 | up to 4 |
| Type 3 | up to 12 |
| Type 4 | up to 26 |
| Type 5 | up to 46 |
| Type 6 | up to 86 |
| Type 7 | up to 160 |
| Type 8 | up to 360 |
In the equivalence table, 1 black bean = 1 defect; other defective beans and impurities (sticks, stones, husks) carry different weights.
Most Common Physical Defects
Black
A bean from fruit that fell to the ground or over-fermented. It tastes earthy, dirty and heavy.
Base defect in the COB and a primary defect for the SCA.
Sour
An over-fermented, brownish bean. It brings vinegary or fermented notes.
"Ardido" in Brazil.
Immature
A bean from unripe fruit. It makes the cup astringent and grassy.
Common with non-selective picking.
Insect Damage
A bean bored by the coffee berry borer (Hypothenemus hampei). Severe damage causes dirty flavors.
Coffee's main pest.
Broken, Shell and Withered
Damaged or malformed beans that roast unevenly.
They hurt roast uniformity.
Quaker
An unripe bean that doesn't darken in roasting and tastes like raw peanut or paper.
Only visible after roasting.
Grading by Cup (Brazil)
Brazil's traditional cupping grades coffee by mouthfeel and taste.
Strictly soft
Very smooth and sweetish, with no defects at all.
Soft
Smooth, pleasant and sweetish.
Softish
Slightly smooth, with mild astringency.
Hard
Harsh and astringent, without strange flavors.
Rioy
A slight iodine-like taste, typical of the "Rio zone".
Rio and Rio Zona
A strong, unpleasant iodine/phenolic taste, associated with the compound TCA.
SCA Standard for Specialty Green Coffee
| Criterion | Requirement |
|---|---|
| Sample | 350g of green coffee |
| Primary defects | None (black, sour, fungus, foreign matter...) |
| Total defects | Up to 5 full defects |
| Quakers | None in the 100g roasted sample |
| Moisture | Between 10% and 12% |
| Cupping | At least 80 points |
Defects that only show in the cup
Some problems are invisible in the bean: the "potato defect" of East African coffees (raw potato smell, linked to a stink bug), the baggy taste of coffee stored too long, and phenolic notes from uncontrolled fermentation. That is why cupping is essential.
Glossary Terms
See full glossary →- Defect
- A flaw in the cup (taint = minor, fault = severe) caused by poor processing, storage, or green bean defects.
- Green Coffee
- Unroasted coffee beans, ready for export and roasting.
- SCA Score
- A 100-point score assigned using the Specialty Coffee Association cupping protocol. 80+ qualifies as specialty coffee.
- Specialty Coffee
- Coffee that scores 80 or above on the SCA scale, free of primary defects, grown in ideal conditions.
- Cupping
- Standardized method of evaluating coffee quality by steeping ground coffee in hot water and tasting with a spoon.
Sources and References
- Brazil Ministry of Agriculture (MAPA): Normative Instruction No. 8/2003, Technical Regulation for Coffee Identity and Quality
- SENAR (2017). Café: classificação e degustação (in Portuguese).
- Specialty Coffee Association: Green Coffee Grading
- Perfect Daily Grind: Brazilian coffee grading explained (in Portuguese)
Let's learn more?