Extraction and Recipes
Understand what happens when water meets coffee and learn to fix any recipe by taste.
What Extraction Means
Brewing coffee means dissolving part of the bean into water. About 30% of roasted coffee's weight is soluble; the rest is fiber that stays in the filter. Of those solubles, we only want a portion: somewhere between 18% and 22% of the weight of the grounds.
Compounds don't all dissolve at once. Acids and fruity aromas come out first, then sugars and body-building compounds, and finally the most bitter and astringent ones. That is why a short extraction tastes sour and an overly long one tastes bitter.
Two numbers sum up a cup: strength (how much coffee is dissolved in the drink) and extraction yield (how much of the grounds was dissolved). They are independent, and understanding the difference solves most brewing problems.
Strength vs Extraction
Two different things that people often mix up.
Strength (TDS)
The concentration of the drink: the percentage of dissolved solids. The SCA standard for filter coffee is 1.15-1.35%; espresso usually sits around 8-12%.
Adjusted mainly with the coffee:water ratio.
Extraction Yield (EY)
How much of the grounds became beverage. The reference range is 18% to 22%. Below that, sweetness is missing; above it, bitterness and dryness take over.
Adjusted mainly with grind, time and temperature.
The Formula
EY (%) = TDS (%) × beverage weight (g) ÷ coffee dose (g). E.g.: 1.35% × 220g ÷ 15g = 19.8%.
TDS is measured with a refractometer.
Diagnosing by Taste
No refractometer? Your tongue solves almost everything.
| What you taste | Likely cause | What to change |
|---|---|---|
| Sour, salty, thin, short finish | Under-extraction | Grind finer, hotter water, more time |
| Bitter, dry, astringent, hollow | Over-extraction | Grind coarser, cooler water, less time |
| Bitter and sour at the same time | Uneven extraction (channeling, fines) | Improve grind quality and distribution |
| Tasty, but weak and watery | Low strength | More coffee for the same water (e.g., 1:16 → 1:15) |
| Tasty, but too heavy | High strength | More water for the same coffee (e.g., 1:15 → 1:16) |
Reference Ratios
| Method | Typical ratio | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Pour-over (V60, Kalita, Chemex) | 1:15 to 1:17 | 15g for 240-255ml |
| Immersion (press, Clever) | 1:14 to 1:16 | 20g for 300ml |
| AeroPress | 1:12 to 1:16 | 15g for 200ml |
| Espresso | 1:1.5 to 1:2.5 | 18g → 36g of beverage |
| Cold brew (concentrate) | 1:5 to 1:10 | 100g for 1L, dilute later |
| SCA Golden Cup standard | ~1:18 | 55g per liter (±10%) |
For pour-over, count the total water poured; some of it stays in the grounds (about 2g of water per gram of coffee).
How to Build Your Own Recipe
- 01
Set the Ratio
Start at 1:16 for pour-over. It controls strength and barely changes extraction.
Tip: Choose the dose by cup size: 15g makes a ~220ml mug.
- 02
Adjust Grind by Taste
Use the grind to move extraction into the sweet zone: neither sour nor bitter.
Tip: Change one step at a time and take notes.
- 03
Use Temperature as a Fine Tune
Light roasts call for 94-96°C; dark roasts, 88-92°C.
Tip: The darker the roast, the easier it extracts.
- 04
Strength Comes Last
With extraction dialed in, adjust the ratio to make the drink more or less intense.
Tip: Changing ratio after nailing the grind keeps you from going in circles.
Numbers serve flavor
The 18-22% range is a reference built from consumer panels, not a law. Very well-grown light roasts, ground on modern grinders, sometimes taste great above 22%. Use the numbers to understand what changed, but always decide by taste.
Glossary Terms
See full glossary →- Extraction
- The process of dissolving soluble compounds from coffee grounds into water. Ideal extraction yield is 18–22%.
- TDS (Total Dissolved Solids)
- Measurement of the concentration of dissolved coffee in water, expressed as a percentage. For filter coffee, the SCA Golden Cup standard suggests 1.15–1.35%.
- Brew Ratio
- The ratio of coffee dose to water used. A 1:15 ratio means 1 g coffee per 15 g water.
- Over-extraction
- Extracting too many solids from the coffee, resulting in harsh, dry, bitter, or astringent flavors.
- Under-extraction
- Too little dissolved from the coffee, resulting in sour, salty, thin, or grassy flavors.
- Refractometer
- A device that measures TDS (Total Dissolved Solids) in brewed coffee to evaluate extraction strength and yield.
Sources and References
- Specialty Coffee Association: Coffee Brewing Control Chart and Golden Cup Standard
- Lockhart, E. E. (1957). The Soluble Solids in Beverage Coffee as an Index to Cup Quality. Coffee Brewing Institute.
- UC Davis Coffee Center: recent research revisiting the Brewing Control Chart
Let's learn more?